April 1, 2015 at 4:41 pm #2899
April 1, 2015 at 8:55 pm #2900therunningheadParticipant
Anyone want to discuss the Eric Taylor book? I’m feeling very happy about finishing it, and it has indirectly helped my playing already, but the answers (‘Model Answers’ book) tells me I don’t understand (in particular) the principles behind (1) ‘More irregular time divisions’ and (2) ‘Intervals’.
For (1), are these things explained in the AB Guide to Music Theory? I got most of Exercise 3 (b) and (c) wrong. Wikipedia is baffling. Can anyone recommend any good links that explain?
For (2), I am completely confused that it is NOT possible, apparently, to say (for example) that an augmented 4th is the same as a diminished 5th. Can anyone explain? And in Exercise 2, third row, third question (treble clef, in E major) a low D# and a Bb sound exactly like a perfect 5th to me, but apparently it’s diminished 6th. Does the name of the interval really just depend on the notation, and not at all on what it sounds like?
Dan (if you’re tuned in to this), your ‘How to work out intervals’ sheet says (at ‘4 o’clock’ position) ‘If a tone lower than the Major | it is Diminished’, but that would mean (in C major) that G would be the diminished of A. Is there something I’m not getting?
If anyone is feeling confused I’m happy to swap confusions with you on this.
April 2, 2015 at 4:55 pm #2901
My first answer would be for you to watch the videos on time signatures and intervals again!
Time signatures are a little difficult to explain in text, perhaps we could do it on the next webinar.
As for intervals – you are spot on, it is down to how it is written, not how it sounds. This harps back to the fact that strictly speaking, D# and Eb are NOT the same note. It is only in our ‘well tempered’ system do they actually become the absolute, same pitch.
In answer to your final point, if I was going from C to Abb then it would be a ‘Diminished 6th’ interval. C to G would be a perfect 5th, but we have not been asked for that.
I suppose it’s a bit like I was told quite frequently at school & college, ‘answer the question!’
Hope this helps.
June 23, 2018 at 5:45 pm #4951jamieParticipant
Just completed this course. What’s an appropriate following course?
September 30, 2018 at 8:34 pm #5646
I’d suggest applying some of it to a transcription project.
There’s around twenty on the site now, so take your pick
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.